Gay lands in Tier 2, with Washington’s offense expected to provide scoring chances. His leg reliability and distance capability offer solid weekly upside in a prolific but sometimes unpredictable offense.

Gay brings stability to Washington after a revolving door at kicker in 2024, offering a safe floor with a career 96.3% extra points and 85.5% field goals. He’s a veteran presence on a squad that needed reliability in the kicking game, and his track record with multiple teams suggests he’ll maintain consistent production. Expect steady weekly points and a favorable indoor-outdoor split depending on the venue and weather patterns. He’s a high-floor selection with upside if Washington’s scoring opportunities stay steady.

Gay’s kicking results in camp show reliability, but the commanders are not committing to a kicker competition yet. A 4-for-5 session, including a miss from 38 yards, keeps the job a live variable as Washington weighs options from 14 free-agent workouts. Fantasy managers should monitor kick setup and any shift in role before Week 1.

Matt Gay's mixed performance in the preseason opener raises concerns for the Commanders' kicking game. After missing a 49-yard attempt, he will need to demonstrate consistency moving forward to hold onto his position.

Matt Gay joins the Washington Commanders, enhancing their kicking game as they aim to lead the league in scoring this season. His experience and accuracy are expected to be critical in tight games, making him a significant asset for the team.